|
Introduction
to the Gerritsen Subject Series
English Language Titles
by Virginia G. Drachman
Assistant Professor
Department of History
Tufts University
Medford, Mass.
General Introduction
The publication of The Gerritsen Collection of Women's History is a major
scholarly event in the evolution of women's history. Until recently interest
in women's history has been limited. What scholarship there was in the
field consisted for the most part of biographies of famous women and histories
of the woman suffrage movement. Recently, historians have broadened their
interest in women's history and have begun to investigate the social conditions
of women's fives. Consequently, women's history has become an integral
part of American and European social history.
With the expansion
of the field, historians have begun to seek out a wider variety of sources
for their research. For example, they have uncovered club records to learn
about women's organizational activities, examined popular health and hygiene
literature to understand the historical issues regarding women's health,
and delved into advice books on childrearing and home management to learn
more about woman's role within the family. Unfortunately, the material
has been scattered, often uncatalogued, and generally not easily accessible
to researchers.
The publication of
the Gerritsen Collection is a significant breakthrough for historians
of women. It represents a major collection of materials on women's history
which will be readily accessible to researchers through libraries.
The collection is
noteworthy for its size, scope, and diversity. It contains substantial
material relating to women's experiences in the public arena, as well
as a wealth of material dealing with all aspects of women's lives within
the home. It is within the home that most women have spent the majority
of their lives and consequently it is here that many historians have begun
to focus their attention. Women's history and history of the family have
developed together and fed each other. Consequently, much of the material
in the Gerritsen Collection signals an advance in the history of the family
as well. In fact, the collection is a major contribution to social history
in general and symbolizes the emergence of women's history as an integral
part of it.
Bibliography
Bibliographies share either authorship, publisher, subject matter, or
a particular point of view. They list certain information, including authorship,
publisher, number of editions, dates of issues, etc. and often contain
short annotations-which give descriptive information on the subject matter.
Bibliographies are
invaluable to the scholar. They facilitate all phases of his or her research
and are especially useful in the initial search for materials. For this
reason, the bibliography section of the Gerritsen Collection will be of
particular interest to historians. For example, the Catalogue of the Galatea
Collection ... of the Boston Public Library (A 318.1) is a bibliography
of its 1100-volume collection on women's history. The American Association
of University Women's bibliography of titles on higher education for women
(A 62.1) is a valuable compilation of materials on related topics, including
co-education, occupations for college women, and the health of college
women. The bibliography by Chase Woodhouse (A 3188 and A 3189) on occupations
for college women supplements the A.A.U.W. bibliography with titles from
the early decades of the twentieth century. Though the titles in this
section are few, they compile a large body of material and uncover many
obscure or lost titles.
History and Social
Condition
The history and social condition category is the most general one in the
Gerritsen Collection. This section includes material which examines woman's
relationship to her culture and to her historic period. Much of the material
in this section includes writings on the lives of women in other countries,
and thereby provides opportunities for interesting cross-cultural comparisons.
Ethel Higginbottom's ... Close-Up Views of India's Womanhood (A 1255)
is a good example of the material on women in other societies. This category
also includes overviews of the history of women or of particular groups
of people. The Social Position of Woman in Different Periods of History
by Jacob Helfenstein (B 1224) and The Hebrew Family by Earle Cross (A
623) are good examples. Also in this section are analyses of woman's political,
social and economic status. A good example is The Woman of To-morrow (A
3133).
Another major topic
in this category concerns marriage, home and motherhood. The home and
family have been defined as women's domain. While it has been men's responsibility
to venture forth into the world to work, women have been assigned the
role of maintaining the home-cooking, cleaning, sewing, etc. Beyond these
domestic tasks, however, women's central role in the family has been that
of wife and mother. As wives women were to provide their husbands with
a warm, safe environment to which they could retreat from the aggressive,
dog-eat-dog world outside. As mothers, women were responsible for childbearing,
and most importantly, for their children's education.
In the mid-nineteenth
century, women's responsibilities in the family culminated in a cult of
true womanhood which defined women's role of wife and mother as the natural
extension of women's biological capacity to reproduce. Simultaneously,
a genre of literature appeared to educate women in the ways of fulfilling
their responsibilities of wife and mother.
Selections from the
Gerritsen Collection in this category, such as Mary Mason's The Young
Housewife's Counsellor and Friend (A 1872.1), provided women with advice
on caring for their families and managing their households. Others such
as Robert West's A Father's Letters to His Daughter (A 3078.1) romanticized
these responsibilities and idealized true womanhood. Similarly, William
Alcott's series of books to women on wifehood, motherhood, and domesticity
seem to cover all the areas of concern to women in their role as center
of the family. While these advice books were most popular in the last
half of the nineteenth century, they continued to be read and new ones
were written well into the twentieth century.
Education and Professional
Training
Education has always been deemed an essential ingredient in upward mobility.
For oppressed groups, in particular, it has been seen as the key to success.
Women as a group have been no exception.
Historically, the
education of women has been a controversial issue. In preindustrial society,
it was only the women of the upper classes who had access to any sort
of education. Generally, their education was directed toward developing
them as proper ladies. More emphasis was placed on learning French, piano,
needlepoint, etc. than on learning mathematics, Latin and history.
The early nineteenth
century began to witness the demand by women for schools of their own,
and during the second half of the century women began to open their own
academies and colleges. Despite the rapid progress in this movement for
women's education, there were many who opposed it. Opponents argued that
mental activity was dangerous to women's physical health. Furthermore,
they feared that education would attract women away from their homes and
thereby threaten the stability of society.
The Gerritsen Collection
contains excellent examples of all aspects of women's education from Emma
Willard's early plea in A Plan for Improving Female Education (A 3110)
and Edward Clarke's popular book, Sex in Education (A 540), which argued
that intellectual activity was dangerous to women's physical health, to
the defense of women's higher education by nineteenth century feminists,
such as Julia Ward Howe's Sex and Education (A 1319) and Helen Starrett's
discussion of the problems college-educated women often faced in After
College, What? (A 2723). In this category falls a wide range of titles,
both wellknown and obscure, on the history of education for women.
Women and Employment
While the proper place for women has always been defined as the home,
in reality most women throughout history have worked. In pre-industrial
society they cooked, cleaned, raised produce, managed the dairy, etc.
With the advent of industrialism, women were the first people to enter
the factories.
The material in this
category falls essentially into two subdivisions, women in industry and
women in the professions. Most women who have worked have done so out
of necessity, to supplement what their husbands brought home or because
they were single or widowed. These women generally worked at low-level
industrial jobs which required little or no skill and for which they received
low wages.
The titles in this
category cover a variety of issues relevant to these women, ranging from
Horace Haines' discussion of Utah's minimum wage law for females (A 1142)
and the Consumer's League of New York's pamphlet The Forty Eight Hour
Law (A 581) to Grace Pugh's survey of women workers in Working Women and
Children in Pennsylvania (A 2288).
In contrast to women
working for wages are women working in the professions. Teaching and nursing
have historically been professions filled by women. In addition, women
have been physicians, business women, lawyers, writers, etc. The literature
here on professional women, such as Medical Women in Tenements by Mary
Damon (A 643) and the National Federation of Business and Professional
Women's Clubs' collection of data on professional women (A 1993), illuminate
the issues unique to women working in the professions.
Also included in the
general category of work are books and pamphlets which advised women on
ways to earn a living. This material varied from offering vocational advice,
as in Eleanor Martin's Vocations for the Trained Woman (A 1852), to Ross
Breniser's instructions in Home Work for Women (A 359), on how to turn
domestic tasks into marketable skills. The large selection of titles in
this general category illustrates that work has always been central to
women's lives.
Feminism
Feminism, as defined in the dictionary, is the doctrine advocating equal
rights for women with men in regard to political, economic, and social
status. There was no place for feminism in pre-industrial society. By
the latter part of the eighteenth century, however, the first signs of
feminism began to appear in Europe. It grew essentially out of an age
when respect for the natural rights of mankind prevailed in theory in
Europe and America. Mary Wollstonecraft's A Vindication of the Rights
of Woman (A 3151) was the first significant feminist publication, serving
as a model for subsequent treatises on women's rights.
Feminism made its
appearance in the United States in 1848 at the first Woman's Rights Convention
in Seneca Falls, New York. The movement expanded in the United States,
England, and other countries throughout the latter half of the nineteenth
century and into the twentieth. It culminated in the United States with
the winning of suffrage for women in 1920. Its energy dissipated thereafter
and feminism lay dormant for several decades until it re-emerged in the
1960's.
The Gerritsen Collection
has materials in this section that are unique and exciting. Included,
for example, are the reports and proceedings of the Woman's Rights Convention
in Seneca Falls, as well as those of subsequent conventions in Worcester,
Akron, and New York. There are also writings of leading feminists, for
example, Elizabeth Cady Stanton's The Woman's Bible (A 2718). Thomas Smith's
The Woman Question (A 2669) contains essays by prominent feminists, including
Ellen Key and Havelock Ellis.
One also finds more
obscure but equally important works on the subject. Helen Moody's The
Unquiet Sex (A 1979) describes the "new" woman for a popular
audience and John Martin's Feminism, Its Fallacies and Follies (A 1854)
presents the feminist and anti-feminist perspectives on the woman question.
An important part
of the feminist movement was the development of women's organizations
and clubs. In colonial days women came together in groups at quilting
bees, while in the early years of industrialization they formed mite societies
to raise money for their churches. The second half of the nineteenth century
witnessed the emergence of large numbers of women's clubs. Women formed
clubs for all sorts of reasons, ranging from selfculture and personal
uplift to unionization and social reform. These clubs continued to proliferate
at such a rate that by the last quarter of the nineteenth century there
was a genuine woman's club movement in the United States, Jane Croly's
The History of the Woman's Club Movement in America (A 618) is the classic
social history of this movement.
The titles on this
topic in the Gerritsen Collection range from literature on some of the
largest and most influential women's organizations, such as the National
American Woman Suffrage Association, the National Women's Trade Union
League of America, and the National Council of Women of Canada, to literature
of smaller, local organizations, such as the New York Association of Working
Girls' Societies and the Girls Trade Education League of Boston. Alice
Winter's The Business of Being a Club Woman (A 3134) and Kate Roberts'
The Club Woman's Handybook of Programs and Club Management (A 2403) are
good examples of the literature advising women on club activities, club
management, etc.
Physiology of Women
At the root of woman's oppression throughout history lies her female physiology.
Woman's biological capacity to reproduce and her inability to control
it until very recently, has meant that most women have spent the reproductive
years of their lives at home childrearing and childbearing. In addition,
constant childbearing was dangerous and often destroyed women's health
permanently, while the inability of medical science to offer accurate
diagnoses and reliable cures meant that women often suffered endlessly
from female-specific diseases for which they can now usually seek helpful
medical treatment. Hence, it is not surprising that many women were weak
and sickly and that many people defined this as natural to womanhood.
Others, however, insisted that women should be healthy and strong and
that it was the realities of their lives, not an inherited pathological
constitution which explained their ill-health. By the mid-ninteenth century
popular health books began to appear advising women on how to stay healthy.
The American Lady's Medical Pocket-book (A 66.1) and Catherine Beecher's
Letters to the People on Health and Happiness (A 198.1) are excellent
examples of the popular literature directed at the issue of women's health.
Among other interesting
topics included in this category are those centering around the issue
of work and health. Margaret Welch's Is Newspaper Work Healthful for Woman?
(A 3073), and the pamphlet Protection of the Health and Motherhood of
the Working Women of Illinois (A 2280) are good examples.
Psychology of Women
With the advent of psychology towards the end of the nineteenth century,
people began to show interest in the psychology of woman, and to the literature
on women's bodies was added literature on women's mental state as well.
Florence Tuttle's The Awakening of Woman (A 2879) and Laura Hansson's
Studies in the Psychology of Woman (A 1171.4) attempt to present psychological
interpretations of woman and her social position.
The relations between
the sexes were influential on the emotions and mental state of women.
While men stand alone, women stand with men. For most women throughout
history their identity and social status have come from the men in their
lives, usually their fathers and then their husbands. Consequently, much
of the writings on women have discussed them in relation to men. Most
interaction between men and women has occurred within the private sphere
of the home rather than in the world outside. The literature on the relations
between the sexes in the Gerritsen Collection reflects this and focuses
primarily on the relationship of women and men to each other as marriage
partners and as sexual partners.
Works like Cecil Chapman's
Marriage and Divorce (B 511) focus on the inequities between women and
men in marriage and argue for changes such as liberalized divorce laws.
Others such as Sarah Grand's The Modern Man and Maid (A 1079.7) offer
advice to women and men on the character traits to seek in a marital partner.
The U.S. Bureau of the Census provides data on marriage and divorce in
the United States from 1867 through 1906 (A 2905).
Also included are
sociological and historical studies of the institution of marriage which
allow for cultural and historical comparisons. In addition, there are
selections focusing more specifically on women and men's sexual relationships.
Eliza Duffey's Relations of the Sexes (A 743) and Iwan Bloch's The Sexual
Life of Our Times (B 290.1) offer two uniquely different approaches to
sexuality, the former from the perspective of a nineteenth century feminist,
the latter from that of a twentieth century German physician. Overall,
these selections are particularly interesting because they reflect social
attitudes toward the private aspects of women's and men's lives.
Biography and Autobiography
Though women as a group have historically been treated as unequal to men,
individual women have always managed to assert themselves and to accomplish
great deeds. Regardless of historical periods or cultural circumstances,
every nation has had its share of influential women to whom it points
with pride.
The Gerritsen Collection
contains a large selection of biographies and autobiographies of famous
women throughout history. For example, Anna Gordon's The Life of Frances
E. Willard (A 1069) provides an intimate biography of the founder of the
Women's Christian Temperance Union; and Helen Dyer's biography of Pandita
Ramabai (A 766) records the life of a leader in the struggle for women's
education in India.
Women have always
looked with pride on the accomplishments of other women. They have seen
these accomplishments as evidence of women's equality with men and as
justification for their demands for equal rights. Perhaps this motivated
the books they often wrote of biographical sketches of accomplished women.
Phebe Hanaford's Daughters of America (A 1168) and Cornelia Love's Famous
Women of Yesterday and Today (A 1760) are excellent examples of this genre.
Opinions, Satires,
Anecdotes, Aphorisms
Woman has historically been a subject which has provoked all sorts of
opinions. Men have seen women as separate and different from themselves
and hence worthy of study and comment. Women, living within a society
that defines them as such, have written treatises about themselves.
People express their
opinions in different ways. Some write serious dissertations, others make
their point through satire, while still others rely on proverbs to express
their ideas.
The Opinions section
of the Gerritsen Collection is small, for the most part because material
that might have been categorized here could be listed under a more specific
heading. Nevertheless, there are some very interesting selections in this
category. Laurens Maynard's Women and Other Enigmas (A 1891), is filled
with witticisms and satire which express contemporary social attitudes
towards women and their relationships with men. William Clark's Woman
and Her Wits (A 544) is a collection of proverbs on woman, love and beauty.
Lucy Aikin's Epistles on Women (B 34) is a collection of poems reflecting
the sentiment that there are no human traits which are exclusively masculine
or exclusively feminine.
Despite the diversity
of expression in this part of the collection, the materials all reveal
attitudes about women's status and proper social role.
Political and Social
Reform
Women have quite often been at the forefront of agitation for political
and social reform. Perhaps because they have borne so many of society's
inequities, they have understood the need for change. For example, women
were actively involved in the anti-slavery and the temperance movements
in the United States. Catherine Beecher's An Essay on Slavery and Abolitionism
(A 1983) advises women of their duty to fight for the abolition of slavery,
while Frances Willard's Woman and Temperance (A 3112.1) recounts the history
of the Women's Christian Temperance Union and of women's leadership in
the movement to abolish liquor.
Towards the end of
the nineteenth century through World War I, suffrage was the cause which
attracted the most attention among women, and there are many titles dealing
with suffrage in this division of the Gerritsen Collection. The writings
of Carrie Chapman Catt, President of the National American Women's Suffrage
Association, for example, explain the arguments and strategies of the
suffrage movement just prior to its success. William Bowditch's Woman
Suffrage, a Right Not a Privilege (A 334) is an example of a male supporter
of the cause. The reports of meetings of the National Society for Women's
Suffrage in London deal with the early movement for the franchise of women
in England (B 2042), while the The Anti-Suffrage Essays by Massachusetts
Women (A 86) provides examples of the sentiments of those opposed to women
voting.
Also included in this
category is material dealing with women's philanthropic and social work.
Examples are More Than the Vote (A 1672) by Robert Leigh and The Relation
of Women To Municipal Reform (A 2016) by Mary Mumford.
Another topical area
of interest in this section is the legal status of women. Woman's legal
status is a valuable barometer of her position in a given society. One
of the largest obstacles to women's emancipation has been the legal system
which has historically upheld one set of laws for women and another for
men. Throughout history women have fought to change those laws which have
legalized and institutionalized their inequality. Their efforts have been
concentrated in two general areas, the laws affecting women's political
status and the laws determining their social position.
The Gerritsen Collection
material on legal status parallels this dual focus and contains literature
dealing with women's legal position vis-a-vis her role as a citizen and
her role as wife and mother. The Legal and Political Status of Women in
the United States (A 3129) by Jennie Wilson, and The Comparison of Political
and Civil Rights of Men and Women (A 1359) by the Inter American Commission
of Women are excellent examples of that body of literature concerned with
the laws defining women's political and civic position in society. Richard
Kathren's Let's Civilize the Marriage Laws (A 1469) and Annie Porritt's
Laws Affecting Women and Children in the Suffrage and Non-Suffrage States
(A 2253) illustrate the concern with the laws affecting women and divorce,
custody of children, married women's property right, etc. Other books
on women's legal status provide historical overviews of the laws relating
to women, from ancient times up to the twentieth century. Ann Chapman's
The Status of Women Under the English Law (B 510), for example, reviews
women's legal status in England from the eleventh century through the
early twentieth. As a body, the literature in this category helps to illustrate
the ways in which the legal system has controlled and simultaneously reflected
women's position in society.
|